You are invited to join a discussion of a chapter of Kyla Wazana Tompkins’ book “Deviant Matter: Ferment, Intoxicants, Jelly, Rot” (NYU Press, 2024) at the annual meeting of the American Anthropological Association in St. Louis. The SAFN Book Club will meet on Saturday, 11/21, from 7:30pm-10:00pm in Conference Center Room 266. For more details on the chapter that will be discussed, email Ariana Gunderson (arianagunderson@gmail.com) or check your SAFN listserv email. Here are some ideas to provoke your thoughts on the book from the organizers.
On “Jelly,” in “Deviant Matter: Ferment, Intoxicants, Jelly, Rot” (NYU Press, 2024) by Kyla Wazana Tompkins. Prepared for the SAFN Book Club, 11/21.
Ariana Gunderson, Dr. Andrew Mitchel, and D.H. We
Kyla Wazana Tompkins starts her book Deviant Matter with a story of failed Jello. And, folks, it failed spectacularly. Ease was not achieved. Belonging was not met. Gelatin was, and is, positioned to make the “jiggle” visible, indeed, to visualize and hold onto that which we typically only feel and speak about. Tompkins argues that these various states of materials have uncanny sensual qualities that render them deviant: ferment; intoxication, rot, and, as will be the core focus of our discussion, jelly. She writes that each of them “catalyze feeling; they provide disciplinary responses aimed at containment… they are defined by transformation; and they act in uncannily agential ways” that struggle to be controlled (4, my emphasis). They are not only situational, temporal, minoritized, and gendered, but they are to be brought back into order through, and by, specific policies, techniques, and processes done onto them by social and state actors demanding control of not just the culinary, but also the aesthetic.
The text’s first chapter is an extensive theoretical section on the politics of these altered states using Foucault’s work on security and population to comprehend a broader societal arc focused on stamping out deviance. Tompkins calls this sensory discordance, which is truly the removal of anything that does not follow convention; it is a securitization to reduce perceived harm or danger (to whom, that is the question) (12). Thus, when we ‘think’ with these matters, we understand there to be not just a biopolitical policing of bodies (as described by Foucault and expounded upon by Mbembe’s necropolitics) but also what Paxson calls the “microbiopolitic” through sterilization (or Pasteurization when it takes on the name of its ‘inventor’) to sanitize in a totalizing way that maintains a keen status quo of ‘proper’ agriculture and, indeed, of proper self-expression (see Paxson 2008). Hygiene, when viewed in this light, becomes a style that, as Tompkins concludes at the end of this chapter, establishes “new norms of scientific comportment to organize and present itself” (51). What we learn is that docility, quantification, dispossession, and a rhetoric of ‘clean food and drugs,’ while having a noble angle to protect people from false remedies, contaminated foods, and disease and illness, also has an aesthetic bend toward uprooting all things viewed as unsanitary, at all times, and in all sites (35). We see this extended metaphor as having ramifications for not just food, drink, and drugs, but a broader vision for society-wide policing of norms of ‘goodness.’
This logic is then applied by Tompkins to ferment, intoxication, and rot, which here I will only discuss briefly as our focus will be on jelly. Ferment extends an emphasis on uprooting the so-called ‘unclean’ microbial morass, which is anthropomorphized as in essence an angry mob that pollutes the body (and, potentially, the soul and the mind). Tompkins’ main example in this chapter in a Louisa May Alcott story about candy and sugar with a deep racial commentary: at the conclusion, its Black character giving up his soul to satiate the White character and ensure “her reabsorption into futurity” (76). This calls to mind broader commentary on energy transfers; captive labor; and a general notion of ‘rightness’ in a necropolitical sense of who can live and who should, or must, die. Tompkins’ next chapter describes intoxication, especially moments where all substances seen as intoxicating were made to be illegal within movements like Prohibition and the War on Drugs. Ferment is said to be a “perversion from within” (89) that causes personal and then society-wide disorder, yet, in some moments, it is precisely an intoxicant that is called into action to heal: we see this in Coca-Cola’s original marketing, and in the example Tompkins gives of Swift’s Syphilitic Specific, which was, in essence, raw botanicals suspended in an alcohol solution. Her examples here draw upon the carnivalesque performance of merriment experienced by those using these tonics and other ‘solution’ to ‘cure’ themselves of, again, like the mobocracy discussed above, a “frenzied and undisciplined [state of] multiplication” (120) with the potential to overtake civility and social order. Tompkins then contextualized rot within a rhetoric of survivance and death, especially when we consider what is discarded in both literal and figurative terms. The core example in this chapter is the chaos and ‘dirtiness’ of urban centers like New Orlean; while sanitizing its streets and ensuring the Mississippi River is not polluted by garbage, human waste, and slaughterhouse runoff will prevent disease, the power over these process shifts to the state and this “hygiene-oriented administrative violence” (150) opens the door to additional types of regulatory practices that polices the ‘unhygienic’ Black body. This objectification of rot and decay as having a personhood to be stamped out again draws our collective attention to rot that survives and what that might mean in our current disciplinary and research contexts.
Jelly is first found in this text from the film Snowpiercer, where (spoiler alert) the masses soon learn that, in this postapocalyptic world following collapse of global order caused by climate change (imagine that), they are being fed cubes of gelatin and pulverized roaches. The rage that comes from this realization unveils that which jelly, or Jello, captures as it is an industrial byproduct that is turned into something that is said to feed or satiate certain populations: the poor, the ill and infirm, the young, and the old (176). Tompkins moves to describe the physics, or rheology, of the ‘jiggle;’ the substance bounces back. It distributes, disrupts, and maybe even redistributes our sensory order. One of the core examples in the excerpt for our discussion is the poor man’s pudding: the description of this gruel provides insight into class differences in consumptive practices (the you-actually-eat-that of ethnocentric beliefs about those from around the worlds and of different class ranks) (188). Tompkins makes the claim that distinction is a material state of being wherein viscosity works to separate us; the labor performed by differing classes is also gelatinous: “it is dead, but it moves; it is solid, but soft” (192). This flow is the politics of jelly, and the hasty pudding is also, eventually, polluted by roaches. The jiggle, too, offers an erotics of care, wherein our bodies can move like Jello when we analyze the haptics of the movement back and forth of a shaking ass.
Tompkins’ conclusion posits all these examples offer us a deeper understanding of an atmosphere of aesthetic violence. It is administrative violence; it is a hygiene applied to all people based on class, race, gender, ableist rhetoric, and more; and a gaslighting into an embodiment of moral righteousness (at least that is my reading). Deviance accumulates: how then do we still find its joy and effervescence under these conditions of its broader policing and an aesthetic that devalues these material states?
